Garnish with a Luxardo cherry, or express an orange twist over the drink and drop it in.
If the balance is off
Tastes like soda: Too much syrup, or a bottled extract that is louder than the homemade reduction. Drop to ½ oz. With Sprecher, start at a bar spoon.
Thin and sweet: 80-proof bourbon gets lost under the cola. Use rye, or a bonded or 100-proof bourbon.
Needs more cherry: Switch to cherry bitters, or add a Luxardo cherry. Angostura keeps the drink in Old Fashioned territory. Black walnut or chocolate bitters pull it toward dessert. Homemade bourbon cocktail cherries work if you are out of Luxardo.